The greet of steel to steel, the fumble of a key: a locker door is flung wide, the contents beyond quickly examined. There was no permission given to see them. There were no questions asked. Instead the locker was merely commandeered by a principal, was forced open. And the results of a search offer illegal substances, the dangerous addictions. They’re stacked so neatly inside.
And the owner of those drugs — a student, summoned from class — is already howling about his rights, the violations of amendments. He is to be protected from unlawful seizures (he remembers that from the endless television shows he’s watched, the Miranda codes he’s heard again and again). This isn’t legal, he argues. This isn’t fair.
But it is — and students must understand why.
In the majority of scenarios no search can be conducted with proper cause (and an accompanying warrant). Homes, businesses and personal property are to be secured against random quests and police interference. Individuals have expectations of privacy and these must be protected.
School lockers, however, are not awarded such favor. They belong to the educational system, not to the individuals who are using them for the year. This translates to a complete lack of the aforementioned privacy. No students can claim that they were violated as they did not own the lockers that were searched. They merely borrowed them and this is not enough to sustain an unlawful seizure claim.
The rights of students are as vital as those of adults. There are distinctions, however, that must be made — and this is one of them. The safety of all within a school must be maintained; and lockers must be made available to any inquests that are necessary. The need to secure the majority outweighs all individual freedoms.
All students must recognize this and be aware that their lockers do not belong to them. They cannot therefore demand privacy. It will never come.







